Welcome to Woodworking for Mere Mortals.

Woodworking videos, easy projects, and entertainment for people who want to have fun building stuff in their garages and shops.


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Saturday, October 2, 2010

Making woodworking entertaining: what Hollywood could do.

This is part two of my article about the dearth of woodworking shows on T.V. Please read part one: Where are the T.V. woodworking shows?

Television money guys need to understand that woodworking is quite popular and that they could actually make money producing a woodworking show. But first, we need to scrap every preconceived notion we have about woodworking shows. Start from scratch and look at them as entertainment first, education a distant second. Take a cue from what’s actually happening on T.V. today. People who watch American Chopper are unlikely to build a motorcycle but we watch because of the highly charged, confrontational personalities of Paul Sr. and Paul Jr. As an upshot, we learn a little about metal fabrication, which would normally be a very dry subject for T.V. I’ll bet American Chopper has inspired more than a few people to get off their duffs and do something with their hands or even decide to learn a trade.

A caveat to fellow woodworkers

Now, I don't mean to upset woodworkers with my suggestions, but none of my ideas for shows will teach you how to make anything step-by-step. Again, I don't think television is the proper medium for detailed instruction. Thirty minutes is not enough time to teach anything properly. These shows would exist purely for entertainment. But they may have the capability to inspire — something that is possible in thirty minutes.

My pitches to Hollywood

So Hollywood, here are a few woodworking show ideas to consider. Any of these would appeal to the general viewing public without alienating woodworkers. Let’s face it, there is nothing duller than watching someone glue up boards or drill a hole, so each of these shows focus on the personalities involved.

"I Got Axed". Twenty people from all walks of life who know nothing about woodworking are selected based on their enthusiasm and outgoing personalities to work alongside professional mentors. Each week they face various challenges to build simple projects. Maybe one week they each have to design and build a birdhouse or a cutting board. Along the way, viewers are exposed to the woodworking techniques and machines the contestants use. Each week, a panel of judges evaluates the finished pieces and eliminates one contestant from the show.

"The Wood Life". Conduct a nationwide search for quirky and charismatic professional woodworkers. Find one shop, bring in the cameras, and chronicle its activities in an ongoing fashion. Like American Chopper, the key is to highlight dynamic interpersonal relationships. But we also get to learn a thing or two about professional furniture making.

"Extreme Wood". Each week, a knowledgeable host travels the world to visit its most highly skilled wood craftsmen and artists: especially those who are employing unique and unusual techniques. Maybe a guy who built his car out of wood, or someone who makes classical Greek sculptures out of wood scraps. Essentially, this would be a travelogue. The host would get a chance work alongside the craftsman, trying out his or her techniques.

"I Made That!" This is the closest I come to a traditional “how-to” show. It would work best on the DIY Network perhaps, and be geared toward people who are already doing a little woodworking, or those who are considering it. The point is to be inspirational. It would feature a dynamic host woodworker who creates a simple project each episode suggested by viewers. Keep it fast-paced with quick editing and lively music. Heavily connect it to a web site on which viewers can collaborate and come up with projects they want to see the host try on the show. Maybe include contests for ideas whereby the winners get to appear on the show and make their projects with the host each week.

"Master Woodworker". Professional woodworkers and cabinetmakers audition to be on the show. They are each given one hour and a limited amount of tools and wood to create something. Each week, we follow each of them around their shops as they create projects for the weekly challenge. Challenges could be as simple as making something cool with a 2x4, then build up to an heirloom piece of furniture. Professionals will dish out sassy judgment each week and eliminate one contestant until the final week when one will be crowned “America’s Master Woodworker”.

"Celebrity Wood". Celebrities team up with mentors who teach them basic woodworking techniques. Each week they construct imaginative, artistic pieces. Imagine the hijinks when Ozzy Osbourne tries his hand at making a guitar stand. How funny would it be to see Paris Hilton whining about sawdust while constructing a makeup kit? Let’s get William Shatner to hand carve a phaser. Now that’s entertainment!


Well there you have it. Woodworking will never be viable on television until it steps into the 21st century and embraces the medium. Many young people are taking up woodworking and yet  the average American still views woodworking as something only for boring old bearded men. As soon as producers discover the entertainment potential of woodworking, I suspect many advertisers will jump at the opportunity. Tool companies could shed their stodgy reputations and appeal to a new generation. It would also be a boon to the woodworking community. Shop classes may reappear in high schools. Kids would get interested in the craft and possibly get inspired to continue its tradition — but with a fresh and new found sense of fun and possibility.

15 comments:

  1. DUDE! I pray that some producers read your posts. Those are all golden ideas. Celebrity Wood lol.. just hope they dont chop their pretty little fingers off. ;) I think Extreme Wood would be my favorite, but hard to tell without seeing them. Great Post.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You have hit the nail on the head. I mention Roy Underhilll and my frinds say "DIY Network?" If I see another bathroom or kitchen remodel I'll test my table saw for flesh detection. My PBS doesn't show Roy or Norm or Dr. Who for that matter anymore. We need more Wood working shows!
    Bill Akins

    ReplyDelete
  3. Is this pre- or post-caffeine?

    ReplyDelete
  4. This truly hits at the heart of the matter. To get people's attention nowadays, you've got to entertain them first. Even the aforementioned kitchen remodels on DIY center around the experience of the homeowner, NOT the remodeling techniques. Most people don't seek knowledge on their own - you've got to sneak it in on them. The article is a bit tongue-in-cheek, but you've truly hit on a strategy that could be useful!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Mere Mort......this is an old premise....the idea of applying this entertainment model to woodworking has been discussed. Can't tell you how many conversations included..."that's what Sr would do". Right down to when you write the biography.

    The logistics of finding the right people is a big issue. Lets not forget that Jr proved he's no Marc Newson and in order to keep the "personalities" intact had to go back to reinterpreting motorcycle design.

    Over time we'll see what happens, but the Rough Cut TV show gets the ball rolling. If anything it puts to rest where I've read and heard that funding a woodworking show won't happen.

    Mere Mort, I said this before in the internet woodworking community that for a generation that grew up on Pearl Jam, this new generation sure does follow alot. When woodworkers stop following the purchasing power of the grey beards; woodworking will get really, really exciting.

    Lets plant a show seed of 2 young guys and grey beard from an old stogy woodworking club.

    It's about making the idea happen, not having the idea anymore.

    Neil

    ReplyDelete
  6. I want to see "Master Woodworker"!!! Hollywood, make it happen! There are enough motorcycle building and home remodeling shows already, show us the wood!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hi Steve.
    I am a viewer of American Chopper who happens to also be building my own bike. (trike actually).
    It will also include my other love, wood working, as I will be making part of the body from wood.
    Love some of your ideas for shows. How about an "Iron "Cabinet maker" show?

    BigTiny

    ReplyDelete
  8. And don't forget Ana White from Alaska. Female woodworkers. Yes, we are out there. I dabble, she is amazing.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Much like your suggestion for "I Got Axed" is a show called "Canada's Worst Handyman" where a series of people nominated by their 'friends' demonstrate just how terrible their home improvement skills are whilst at a home renno rehab centre. It is very entertaining and kind of scary knowing that there are people like this who own power tools!

    ReplyDelete
  10. in addition to "Canadas Worst Handyman" theres another canadian show called "Handyman Superstar Challenge" where real pros build/repair various things in a time limit. i don't think it did very well, but it's canadian, and canadian tv shows never do very well...

    ReplyDelete
  11. Ah, like isn't all of that what we got YouTube for? I'm polishing up my latest video. Which is sort of hard to do being as I don't even have a video camera! But so far it is coming out pretty good.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Steve, I love the ideas. Considering how much I currently hate what is on TV, I would watch almost any one of these types of shows. Here is hoping some one with a TV network is reading this. Seems that Canada has a number of shows according to the posts here. Maybe we'll just have to do some more importing.

    CtL

    ReplyDelete
  13. after katrina I had to temporarily move to nw indiana and wow! this cable company had diynetwork . in july of 2006 we were able to move back to biloxi ms. and we begged our cable company to include diynet. after 4 years of promises we cancelled our cable to get one of the satelite companies that offered diynet. diynet use to have some kickbutt woodworking show from the elitist (my work in ebony and wangee) to the home schmucks like myself in the early mid 2000's we finally cancelled our cable 4 years after returning home to find no i repeat no woodworking shows on diy network!! mips (to quote the coneheads) i am so disapointed no tools & techniques no nothing oh for the good old days of 2005.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Smart thinking. I even watched some of the boring show but those are great ideas. I am with many of the others who hope the TV producers will catch your vision.

    ReplyDelete